Articles | Forums | Polls | Quotes | Who's Online | Store
Signup | Lost Password
"Nature is the greatest modern piece of art; constantly changing, incomprehensively expensive and vandalized by idiots." - Atlantis5
Main -> Social Awareness -> Religion  | NewPosts

If there's a god, why is there evil?

USER THREAD
187 Posts / 62M
     :   19yrs   :  
UnderDawg

This is way off topic now, but o well.

In response to someone asking how there has to be good AND evil, think of it this way. If there were no evil, good in itself would not be considered "good" because it would be the behavior of all beings. If there were no good, evil would not exist because "evil" actions would not be considered evel without having a "good" to compare it to.
Just my thoughts


"My drum skills > Your drum skills"

2 Posts / 62M
     :   22yrs   :  
Yurishima

God gave man the free will to either accept or Deny God. He already knew who was going to accept him or deny him, because he is the all knowing. Even so, God loves us, and let us make our own decisions and we are responsibile for them. Started at the beginning why their is evil (sin) Adam went against God when you choosed to eat a fruit that he shouldn't of ate. It was a test of faith, and he failed. And It was born, evil (sin) on the earth. It's mans own desires to do what they want and not what God wants that creates evil. Man is jealous of many things. Jealousy is also one of the main keys lots of things happen. God knew they were going to turn against him. But God is a loving God, so he sent his son to die for us so that we may have away to him. Once you accept God, you are dead to sin. You no longer have sin that accounts against you to enter heaven. You still can commit sin but aren't bound to it. Sin is evil. Mans own desire, but Gods love that allowed them to even make that chance because he loves us.


238 Posts / 64M
     :   27yrs   :  
Crimson_Saint

Strongclad - 1st The evil and god debate is often one of the main arguments atheists (myself till recently) use against the belief of God. However I studied a bit of Leibniz who treated this subject in class and now I feel it is not impossible for God to exist in a world that has elements that we perceive as evil. So I am still atheist for other reasons.

2nd If God exists, I doubt a book would be able to describe him well.

3rd I believe my stance, that evil exists in some form because it will create a greater good later in a way we cannot understand because it is the only one that is possible.
Evils exist, no denying it and IF God is omnibenevolent, omnipotent and omniscient, then these evils are in fact only perceived evils, and they must lead to greater good.

Though I find it dubious that you trust an outdated book more then your own feel and personal relationship with God. There is no reason to believe the Quran is less true then the Bible.


"AIDS is God's way of sending Catholics to heaven."

238 Posts / 64M
     :   27yrs   :  
Crimson_Saint

Yurishima - Is God a good one if he demands complete and utter obedience? Is he a good God if he creates us knowing we will break his rules and sin (and send us into hell for eternal damnation)?


"AIDS is God's way of sending Catholics to heaven."

65 Posts / 63M
     :   22yrs   :  
Mr. Humble

God doess't ask for our compleate obediance. There was a passage (somewhere) about the other two crosses next to the one that Jesus was crucified on. One of the other people hung was actually a theif, and he said before he died that he believed that the person next to him was Jesus. Jesus responded something like this "I will see you in heaven brother" (or somethin' like that)


""How do you know we exist? Maybe we don't exist." -Vivi FF9"

2 Posts / 62M
     :   22yrs   :  
Yurishima

quote:
Yurishima - Is God a good one if he demands complete and utter obedience? Is he a good God if he creates us knowing we will break his rules and sin (and send us into hell for eternal damnation)?



God does ask for obedience that you give everything to him. But he knows man will not do so. His love never changes because his love is unconditional and unchangable. Yes, he is a good God. An awesome God for that matter. He is the meaning of God, everything he has done is meaning of Good because he cannot do evil.
God is a loving God, but God is also a just God. he loved us so much he sent his son to die for us because he knew. Now your asking if hes a Good God if he sends us to hell knowing we would do so anyways. Yes. He is a good god because he gives all man the opportunity to know him in some circumstances or another. He gives them that chance to either accept or deny. If you choose to deny, you have already Blasphames yourself. Blasphames is an eternal sin, because people who commit it already harden their hearts so much that they already damned themselves to hell. Now, Blasphames is meant for the Faros in that time because its meant for people who actually seen his works and deny that is him and that he may just be the devil. But their is away out of that, accepting and repeanting to God cofessing and knowing he died for our sins etc. But He is saying that man already harden their hearts to much that they probably wouldnt. God did create us in his image, but it was us who went against him. He wants us to glorify him. Again, you ask if he is a Good God. Yes, he is because he gives every opportunity even if you may not realize it to seek him and know him ans your savior.


238 Posts / 64M
     :   27yrs   :  
Crimson_Saint

Tanker - Don't you find it dubious that today's man should be held accountable for the sins of our supposed ancestor?

"God does ask for obedience that you give everything to him. But he knows man will not do so. His love never changes because his love is unconditional and unchangable."
And yet he creates some of us knowing we will sin and casts us into hell forever. No, no sense at all! A good God would simply not create us and spare us the pain.

Finally, I don't think denying God is a sin. Am I destined for hell, do I deserve hell, because in my opinion I've seen little or no reason to believe in God? If God loves me and wants me to love and believe in him then he should show the world some better evidence then a few questionable books.


"AIDS is God's way of sending Catholics to heaven."

187 Posts / 62M
     :   19yrs   :  
UnderDawg

No, we are NOT held accountable for the sin of our ancestor's, we are held accountable for OUR sins. Whether you are Christian or Athiest, no one can deny we do wrong. Whether it be lying to our parents, cheating on a test, or anything of that sort.

God creates us with free will, and you can quote me on this all you want, if you deny God you deserve Hell.

Yes, you are destined for Hell because you deny Him. He has given us proof enough of his existence by this little thing we call THE UNIVERSE. And he hasn't written a few questionable books, he wrote one book that is all that needed to live a fullfilling life as long as you follow its laws. If need be, I can show you some things that prove God, such as, you can go back in the history books and see in the Roman records that a man named Jesus was crucified for the exact same reasons explained in the Bible.


"My drum skills > Your drum skills"

2202 Posts / 64M
     :   49yrs   :  
okcitykid

Strongclad: You're absolutely right - you write to much. Let me see if I can remember all your questions.

1. This thread has been going on since before I got here. I found it and said, wow - cool. Who dare ask such questions? I have not read the entire thread, it is too much for me to read.

2. I disagreed with the Good and Evil question. We could go on forever on that. Mr. Humble brought that up - I suggested he make a new string, he did, it died, and we're back here talking about the same old thing. I say, ah the hell with it, lets talk about it.

3. I read the bible when I was 13. I have been a member of the Catholic Church, Pentecostal Church, LDS and RLDS and everything in between. I am now a member of the Unitarian church. I am well versed on the subject of Christianity - you could not possibly offend me. I hope I do not offend you. I think it is great you believe what you do and it is ok to share as far as I'm concerned. I have also briefly studied all the other major religions. If you was to do this, I think you would be surprised what you might find.

Concerning the question of this thread - I think I have a glimpse of the answer - but I don't think I or anyone else here has the answer. I do believe that the originator of this thread had meant to flounder the belief in God, but I think that the opposite is happening. And it's cool.


"A fool says I know and a wise man says I wonder."

2202 Posts / 64M
     :   49yrs   :  
okcitykid

" If there were no evil, good in itself would not be considered "good" because it would be the behavior of all beings. If there were no good, evil would not exist because "evil" actions would not be considered evel without having a "good" to compare it to.
Just my thoughts" I agree - that goes along with the Ying and Yang thing. But there is an evil we're not understanding. All the religions will in their own way try to teach you the great goodness (becomeing one with God). But what about evil - what is that all about. Maybe I'm reaching, and maybe I should just quit it.


"A fool says I know and a wise man says I wonder."

90 Posts / 62M
     :   27yrs   :  
Strongclad

Crimson_Saint - I wish I could make my case for Christianity in short, but my reasons for believing are more numerous than I would like to write about on this thread. That's why I keep recommending books by authors who know what there talking about in which they tackle the same subjects.

"If God exists, I doubt a book would be able to describe him well."
I'm just making an assumption, and pardon me if I'm wrong, but when you make this statement, I tend to think that you may not have read the Bible or given it a chance. I think that this is why many atheists (and not necessarily you) don't believe in God. Many atheists have already made up their minds in what they believe because they've already closed their minds to the belief in God.

The Bible, is the record of God interacting with humankind throughout history. It contains His words, His actions, and His promises to humanity. In the mix of all of that, you cannot say that it lacks in describing Him. Many scholars, professors, and scientists have written books stating evidence of why the Bible is reliable and trustworthy. Those who wish not to test it have already closed their minds to it.

"Evils exist, no denying it and IF God is omnibenevolent, omnipotent and omniscient, THEN THESE EVILS ARE IN FACT ONLY PERCEIVED EVILS, and they must lead to greater good."
I'm sorry, can you explain what you're meaning by PERCEIVED EVILS?

"Though I find it dubious that you trust an outdated book more then your own feel and personal relationship with God. There is no reason to believe the Quran is less true then the Bible."
Time after time after looking at the claims by people who think that the Bible is contradicting or untrue, I find an author who uses evidence to shoot those claims down. Too many people think the Bible is outdated with out any justification. Just because it has no photographs or videos of the miracles or the things it states has happened, doesn't mean it is untrue. It's like saying that if in the next two thousand years nobody lands on the moon, that the historical event that really did happen must not be trustworthy because it's listed in outdated material.

Sure I have a relationship with God, but in no way can I use my feelings from that relationship as a basis for truth. Feelings may reveal the presence of God in someone's life, but feelings are too subjective to use as a basis for the truth of God. Feelings are personal and can't be used to prove anything really. Our feelings sometimes lie to us as most of you know. There are many people in this world, who get this so called "Spiritual" feeling when they think God is with them. Mormons, Catholics, Protestants, Jews, Muslims, New Agers, all get these feelings, but with all the differing beliefs, not all can be right just because they say they've felt the presense of God. I know someone who is a fan of the Insane Clown Posse and has told me that all their songs are really about God among all their profanity. Whenever she goes to one of their shows, she says she feels the presence of God. But I would bet based on their actions, that they really have no clue what they're talking about.

I wouldn't believe what I believe if it wasn't true. Sure, people from many different faiths say the same thing, but not all come up as reliable when tested.

The Bible is the basis for who we are as Christians. It's our guide for living as God would want us to live. But if you get rid of the Bible and all the information it contains, we have nothing. We wouldn't know who God is and what He has done if His dwellings on earth weren't recorded or handed down in one way or another. No Bible - No Christianity. Tanker summed up Christianity in his post, and all of that is true and based from the Bible.

I don't believe the Qur'an, because of it's claims. I'll give you an example which I'm borrowing from the CHRISTIAN RESEARCH JOURNAL.

The Qur'an is held in the highest position of authority for the Muslim and believe it to be true down to the word. (I guess in a sense it is to Muslims as the Bible is to Christians - it's God's word.) So by that, it must be true if it is from God. But in it's pages there is something wrong.

The Qur'an directly addresses the biblical docturne of the Trinity, and misrpresents it. Note these words:

"They are truly infidels who say:"God is the Christ, son of Mary." But the Christ had only said:"O children of Israel, worship God who is my Lord and your Lord." Whosoever associates a pompeer with God, will have Paradise denied to him by God, and his abode shall be Hell; and the sinners will have none to help them. DISBELIEVERS ARE THEY SURELY WHO SAY:"GOD IS THE THIRD OF THE TRINITY;" BUT THERE IS NO GOD OTHER THAN GOD THE ONE. And if they do not desist from saying what they say, then indeed those among them who persist in disbelief will suffer painful punishment...The Christ, son of Mary, was but an apostle, and many apostles had(come and) gone before him;and his mother was a woman of truth. They both ate the (same) food (as men). Behold, how We show men clear signs, and behold, how they wander astray!...Tell them:"O people of the Book, do not overstep the bounds of truth in your beliefs, and follow not the wishes of a people who had erred before, and led many others astray , and wandered away from the right path."(Sura 5:72-73, 75,77)

It is clear that the Qur'an is not an inspired document, for it is clear that it's author did not understand the doctrine of the Trinity, WHICH ALREADY HAD BEEN ESTABLISHED CLEARLY AND TAUGHT FOR CENTURIES. To say "God is a third of the Trinity" is to completely misrepresent the doctrine. The Father is not a third of God, nor is the Son, nor is the Spirit. Each is fully God. God's being cannot be divided. It is simple(i.e., not compund, not made up of parts)and indivisible.

When it is pointed out to them that the doctrine of the Trinity, in all of it's classical expressions, begins and ends with the affirmation of the unity (indivisibility) of God's being and the absolute truth of monotheism, the response is to question the accuracy of the definitions, for the Qur'an says otherwise! This brings us back to the authority issue and to the fact that the Qur'an misrepresents the doctrine, a fact that demonstrates the true nature of the Qur'an's status as a supposed revelation from God.

So my arguement from this example is to say that there is reason to believe the Qur'an is less true than the Bible. Everything must be based on truth, and not just that, also truth that is knowable. We know that God exists because He has shown us He does. If He didn't, and if we were alone without Him, we might still be sacrificing babies to the Asherahs and the Baals. (check the Old Testament)

I just want to make a suggestion; when you wish to assert the truth of something, give evidence that backs up your claim. I try to do the same in my posts, as I am trying to relay truth. I try not to make assumptions on anything, because when you're trying to make a point to someone, you don't want to assert an ungrounded opinion, or an outright lie.

Like this opinion:"if (IF) homosexuality is evil, then it is not a gay's fault he is evil. Its not his fault he is attracted to men, its not his choice, its his genes."

Has it been proven that genes cause people to be gay? And if it's in the genes, how come there are fathers of homosexuals that aren't gay? If genes are to blame for a persons actions and if they're passed on from your father's genes, shouldn't he be gay too? Or is it just a mutation in the transfer of genes from father to son? Is he just a by-product of so-called evolution? And can that mutation be proven?

These are the aspects of an arguement. Just wanted to state that.

I wish not to offend anyone, that's not my intentions. I'm just assertive in getting things right. I'm pretty anal when it comes to detail and trying to get people to think logically.

Peace.


"All statements are false. The last statement is false.--One of these statements is true."

90 Posts / 62M
     :   27yrs   :  
Strongclad

WOW!!!WHAT A WHOPPER!!!


"All statements are false. The last statement is false.--One of these statements is true."

3 Posts / 62M
     :   24yrs   :  
Deadpool

Hey Yo.

Im new here, but this looks like a pretty rad place to discuss things.

Anyhoo, great writing Strongclad. Never have I seen such an argument put so succintly, or so well written. Precise and to the point without sound too preachy. Well done. Being a Christian myself, it is good to see such people taking such a stand online.

Well done.


"Im not predujiced, I hate everyone equally -WC Fields"

238 Posts / 64M
     :   27yrs   :  
Crimson_Saint

Underdawg - "Yes, you are destined for Hell because you deny Him. He has given us proof enough of his existence by this little thing we call THE UNIVERSE."
There are other explanations for the universe then some omnibenevolent, omnipotent, omniscient entity. The big bang theory has holes in it, but FAR less then the idea of God.

Strongclad - "I'm just making an assumption, and pardon me if I'm wrong, but when you make this statement, I tend to think that you may not have read the Bible or given it a chance."
I've not read the whole thing. I've read numerous extracts though. I've read many of the old testament's laws as well as some of the new testament's, I've read most of Genesis and I have a copy the new testament in my room.
But no, I've never given it a serious read, but from actions of religious people and many extracts of the bible, I've found that its probably an outdated book.

" Many scholars, professors, and scientists have written books stating evidence of why the Bible is reliable and trustworthy."
And many scholars have shown that the book itself contradicts itself many times.

"I'm sorry, can you explain what you're meaning by PERCEIVED EVILS? "
Well, for example, lets say someone who died in the WTC was going to be the next Hitler and would have been responsible for the deaths of millions of people, the WTC attack would ultimately be a good thing. But we always will perceive it as evil.

"The Bible is the basis for who we are as Christians. It's our guide for living as God would want us to live. But if you get rid of the Bible and all the information it contains, we have nothing."
I doubt you are trully living by the BIble's laws, old or new testament. The Bible's laws can be strict and the punishments brutal.

"It is clear that the Qur'an is not an inspired document, for it is clear that it's author did not understand the doctrine of the Trinity, WHICH ALREADY HAD BEEN ESTABLISHED CLEARLY AND TAUGHT FOR CENTURIES. To say "God is a third of the Trinity" is to completely misrepresent the doctrine. The Father is not a third of God, nor is the Son, nor is the Spirit. Each is fully God. God's being cannot be divided. It is simple(i.e., not compund, not made up of parts)and indivisible."
Well perhaps what was being taught for centuries was simply wrong and the Quran corrected the old belief. Just as Christ supposedly came to correct the beliefs of the Jews.


"AIDS is God's way of sending Catholics to heaven."

238 Posts / 64M
     :   27yrs   :  
Crimson_Saint

"Has it been proven that genes cause people to be gay? And if it's in the genes, how come there are fathers of homosexuals that aren't gay? If genes are to blame for a persons actions and if they're passed on from your father's genes, shouldn't he be gay too?"
Its called recessive genes. The "gay" gene wouldn't always express itself if you also have a "straight" gene. But no I have no proof for this claim. But it seems to be the most likely explanation.
Are you attracted to men? Do you have to suppress an attraction to men? If not, then you are different then a gay because he is attracted to men (not by choice) but probably because of his genes or possibly environment.

But in that case, back up your claim. Why does God exist, what is this strong evidence leading to the belief that an omnibenevolent, omnipotent and omniscient entity exists.


"AIDS is God's way of sending Catholics to heaven."

If there's a god, why is there evil?
A1F1T0T1T2T3T4T5T6T7T8T9T10T11T12T13T14T15T16