| 
Unfortunately not too much, just because of the fact that we have to be careful when generalizing and relating god to humans, as a parent, no living parent on earth is and all powerful being, these statements invoking the weight of such notions as infinite power and the creator of all, knowing all, seeing all, foreseeing all. "uh, if they are spiritual... they just can't pick up a gun and pull the trigger/or pick up a flower and give it in love. they kind of need us, here in the physical, to do that work for them..." If he can create physical beings he can control them, if he is all powerful then anything I say he can do he can, all things are included in terms such as anything. Was it specified that angels were given free will? Not that I recall offhand. You said satan decided to desire, is that how desire works? Not that I'm aware of. The free will argument is highly flawed. One, what's the point, why would god offer a choice? If he wants people act a certain way, why would he design them with conflicting desires? To what purpose? Why would he create lying and and deciet and ask us to trust others when they tell of a story that doesn't make sense, conflicts with known reality, and whose good points are so easily scewed and misread and in text and languages that become outdated? Why isn't there a universal god language so we can understand and know we understand, instead of the notion of cryptic messages and mysterious ways. Thats just superstitious rationalizing that every culture naturally does attempting to explain the world around them> What does god gain from us? No, he doesn't need us that's silly, no all powerful being needs anything, it contradicts the idea of all powerful. For us to worship? Why? To stroke god's ego? God is above human emotion so I hear. Its not to find out what will happen in a grand experiment, god already knows all and has written all destiny, as he must, for no creation under god can have power over god, for god is all powerful. If it were more clear what is actually right and wrong this wouldn't be such a problem. Especially according to relgion, the person who decides ultimately what is right and wrong is god, and we are supposed to follow that, well we don't have adequate intelligence or communication with god for such information to be substantiated. God can make it clear to us, no devil of god's creation can overpower the information or power of god. These ideas of a powerless all powerful god are what undermine your argument.
"The Greatest Enemy of Knowledge is Not Ignorance, It is the ILLUSION of Knowledge. Stephen Hawking"
|